Showing posts with label Theory. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Theory. Show all posts

April 22, 2007

Negative Sum Game - Part 1

In his last post, Chris speculated on the possibility of a game in which the protagonist doesn't win and is doomed to failure from the start. This made me curious: how would a game that a player can't win really look. 'Winning' takes on very specific meanings when it comes to video games, so it may not look the way we think it would.

First, let's split games into the two basic categories so we can determine what winning means in different contexts.

  • Narrative-based games: games with a plot that a player is expected to follow. In this type of game, winning can be defined as playing the game through to it's successful conclusion.

  • Round-based games: similar to board games, this type of game is based around a gameplay system that is implemented across different settings. In round based games, in order to win you must defeat other players or achieve specific objectives in a set time-frame or under certain conditions.

Now, there is some crossover between these two types of games, but most eventually fall into one camp or the other. Most modern games are narrative-based games (Gears of War to name but one), and older games were more likely to be round-based (Pacman, Pong, Battle Zone). However, some more recent games are round-based, such as most racing games, the Mario party series, and all competitive multiplayer games currently on the market.

It is very simple to determine what winning is in a round-based game, and that is to beat all the other players, be they human or computer controlled. In this context, games that are un-winnable are games that would not allow players to measure who did the best in any measurable way. This would be tremendously dull. Imagine a racing game where every player has a different track and the game never let any player know if they finished before another player. In the context of a round-based game, an un-winnable game doesn't sound like much fun.

So now we've defined what winning (and not winning) is in a round-based game, how can we define a narrative-based game that cannot be won? Well, the most basic way to lose a game is to die (provided you're not playing Prey). So does that mean in a narrative-based game that you lose the game if your character dies at the end of the story?

Not necessarily. Winning and losing are more complicated than that, because winning is as much an emotional experience as it is a hard-and-fast set of conditions. Winning also means you were successful in what you were trying to do. For example, the T-800 (the Governator) in Terminator 2 'wins' because he A) destroys the T-1000 and B) saves John Connor. However, he has to destroy himself in order to avert Judgment Day (unless you accept Terminator 3 as canon, which I don't). He dies, but he doesn't 'lose,' so even if the protagonist dies at the end of the narrative, he can still win.

What if the main character were to die, and failed the objective the set out to achieve? Now that would be losing! However, games are funny in the way they structure a narrative. Unlike in a movie, where you sit and watch things happen to a character, in a game you are in control of events and you can replay the game as many times as you wish. For these circumstances to result in anything other than 'winning' at some point, then the game itself would have to be designed to result in the failure of the protagonist. But again, we're undermined by the psychological dimension of winning, because in the absence of a traditional positive ending, gamers will feel a sense of accomplishment in having completed the game, overcome any challenges and progressed through the narrative of the game. So we're back at square one again - we've created a different ending, but the player still would feel like they won, since they achieved what they set out to do. Knowing your quest is hopeless from square one makes failure meaningless, and like I said before progress through the game becomes a surrogate for actual success.

Our trouble lies in expectation. Fiction depends to some degree on a willing suspension of disbelief, putting ourselves inside the world or the game, movie or book. In non-interactive fiction, this serves to keep us emotionally invested in the characters of the work, but in a game, where we can take control over the story, suspense isn't usually as sharp because we can react to surprises and no situation, no matter how dire, is ever hopeless because we can take control. Worst of all for narrative structure, if we die, then we jump back before the dangerous event that led to our demise. We can adjust tactics and strategy and best of all, this time we won't have been victims of the element of surprise. As we play through the game, we learn what to expect and adapt our sense of winning to our experiences. So to not win, our expectations have to be subverted. The ending, and how it unfolds, must be a surprise.

So in order to lose in a narrative-based game, the protagonist has to fail, and the player has to not know that this failure is imminent as they play through the game. Otherwise, they simply adjust their expectations to the structure of the narrative. So now, we finally have a working definition of a narrative-based game that is not winnable: a game that leads players to expect they will succeed, but is designed and plotted to result in nothing other than failure. If a player suspects this twist is coming, then the game goes from an un-winnable tragedy to a dark ending to our hero's noble quest.

In the second part of this article, I'll investigate how anyone would even make a game like this, if anyone should, and what losing can teach us about how to make games better.

April 20, 2007

Children of Hurin

I'll admit it, I'm a fan of Lord of the Rings. Despite this fact, I've never played any of the games. The upcoming LOTR MMORPG seems especially interesting, but usually games that are based on existing franchises tend to fall short of their possible greatness. So I have my doubts. LucasArts is the one notable exception to this claim: over the years I've been impressed with how the Star Wars games (Jedi Knight, X-wing & Tie Fighter, especially) have made significant strides in expanding and enriching that universe.

But the LOTR games have always been a disappointment, from what I can tell. I've played bits and pieces of them, and honestly never had a desire to play any of them all the way through. It didn't help that Frodo's stare, the One Ring, and the lidless eye all were given way more screen time than they deserved in Peter Jackson's trilogy. And since the games were so tightly tied to the movie franchise, I was expecting many more hours of a CG Frodo gazing at his CG Precious.

But with the new book The Children of Hurin, I think we have reason to be excited:

"In this way, before the summer had passed, the following of Turin had swelled to a great force, and the power of Angband was thrown back. Word of this came even to Nargothrond, and many there grew restless."
The many restless of Nargothrond... My hope is that these folk will be too restless to stare longingly at the One Ring for hours on end.

There are, however, many reasons to suspect that the new book will not be made into either a book or a movie. CNN's report on the subject states, "This is a gloomy tale -- Hurin's children doomed to failure by Turin's hubris and, of course, the curse." A video game where the protagonist doesn't win? That's a twist worth thinking about.

What if a good LOTR game could be made based on the Children of Hurin, and what if that game flew in the face of all conventional wisdom by being a game in which the curse was more powerful than the game's protagonist. What if the world was in fact doomed, and nothing you could do could stop the power of evil? A game without a happy ending. A game you couldn't win. Now that'd be something.

April 11, 2007

In the words of Woody Allen ...

Those of you who've read this blog, or any of my others, you know that my interests extend beyond that of games. Don't get me wrong, I love them, but there are other things in my life, and at times my interests in one area inform the others.

Among other things, I'm a film buff, and Annie Hall is one of my favorites. Woody Allen used the phrase "mental masturbation" to refer to college courses such as "Contemporary Crisis in Western Man," or "Existential Motifs in Russian Literature." I've always thought this phrase was a great way to describe the sort of pointless, self-aggrandizing intellectualism that one comes across not just in college, but elsewhere in life. Philosophy, psychology, sociology, anthropology, art theory, all of these are important fields of study, but at times they can run amuck. This affliction is not limited to scholars, or the small selection of fields I've listed, they were just the first examples that came to mind. This can even afflict game journalism. The one post in particular that has irked me appeared yesterday on Destructoid.

This post was on an interesting topic. Should games seek to grow beyond the idea of simply being fun? But beyond the premise, the article is a jumbled, rambling, poorly sourced mess that really only serves to advance the author's theories and comes off a lot like someone who wants to hear themselves talk. This article could have made a good round table discussion, or podcast, or a mildly interesting lecture, but as an article, it misses the mark.

I guess the other reason I took issue with this article is that I think it's thesis misunderstands the very nature of videogames, and of entertainment, and the author presents his points poorly and haphazardly. Should videogames try to reach the levels or art that prose, poetry and film have reached? Sure, and I'll try those games. But the real basic point, that doesn't require several thousand words, is that games need better writing. You do this, and the rest of what we want will follow. Have you ever watched a movie by a great screenwriter, and then one by a poor one? Would you be tempted to call one "art," and the other "escapist fun"?

Now here's the kicker: if you enjoy both of them, does the "fun" movie need to evolve into great art, or can we simply enjoy it for what it is? I say we enjoy it.

The title of the post is "Fun isn't enough: why video games have to move beyond escapism." Actually, fun is enough. Fun is the point. If you were to ask me why I love baseball more than any other sport, I couldn't give you reasons more concrete than "I enjoy it," or "I think it's fun to watch and play." That's enough for me, and I've enjoyed it as a part of my life for 24 years, and hopefully I'll be watching it until I die or lose my eyesight (in which case I'll just listen). All because it's fun.

Sometimes you need a masterful portrait of human events and emotion, and sometimes you need the Three Stooges. Sometimes you need a game with a compelling plot that challenges the way you think about the world, and sometimes you need Tetris. Games must remain fun, and them must remain fun first. We can make them better and more complicated, but even in five hardware generations, people will still play Tetris, Mario, hell, probably even Pong. They will play these games because they are fun, and for no other reason. The games described in this article will come about, but they will not be the only species or game left.

Now, the article makes some really dumb mistakes too. Such as:

Instead of looking at WWII as the horrific loss of life than it was, in video games the war is frequently depicted in much the same way it was in the 1940’s: a heroic, unambiguous fight against evil. Good guys die in large numbers, but their deaths are not terribly violent (not a single WWII game I can think of includes blood, much less gibbing). The enemies we fight are faceless and without personality (Call of Duty 2 seems to have about twelve different Nazi models, total).

Factual errors tend to undermine an article, especially when they are phrased like so: "not a single game I can think of includes blood." Well, after 10 seconds on the ESRB page, I found the following

Call of Duty 2 / Activision / T / Blood, Mild Language, Violence

Oh really. How interesting. He couldn't think of (or hadn't played, which is the greater sin) the game he mentions in the next sentence. And as for gibbing, it has gone out of style since ragdoll physics have come into style: why blow a person to pieces if you can watch them crumple and dangle to show off the neat new physics engines? Anyone who has actively played games over the last five years should be aware of this trend.

To the other point he made in the quote, about the exploitation of the seemingly simple good versus evil dichotomy of WWII, yes, simple can be dull, and deprive you of the enjoyment that a rich story with twists, turns and mixed motives might have. But there are plenty of games that actually do this. Despite being dumped on prolifically by Destructoid, Twilight Princess puts you in a situation where you have to assist someone who may or may not have any real interest in helping you, and may well just be using you. This is interesting, and subverts the usual good / evil framework, since you're not really sure what you're doing is good at all. Deus Ex did this as well, and gave you choices about how to move through the game. Oblivion and Morrowind let you reshape the world around your character, engage in political espionage and assassination, become a criminal or vampire, and the variety of the choices and freedom even scared some people off. Games already do all the things he talks about, and they do so outside of Shadow of the Colossus and FF VII which are the untouchable fanboy pillars of esoteric gaming.

Finally, no article, opinion piece or post should ever include any heading as dumb as "Misery is friggin’ awesome." No, actually misery is miserable. We here at FPSS have all know each other for some time, and at times Ben and I have debated how one should approach their emotions. I always held that the most important thing was honesty in expressing how you feel; if you see reasons to feel sad, then feel sad, if you see reasons to be happy, be happy. Ben would say that the negative effects of sorrow and pain can be avoided by changing your frame of mind, and it's more important to focus on trying to keep yourself happy. However, neither of us would endorse the sort of feelings that were put forth in this article:
But misery? Misery, as said above, sticks with you forever. Misery can ruin your life, and fuel your creativity. Misery can give you purpose and drive where simple happiness and contentment lead to stagnation. Not to get any more philosophical or condescending than I already have, but wouldn’t it be interesting to see that misery present in video gaming, as well?

Not to be superior or snarky, but philosophical and condescending peg this article quite well. People (hopefully) grow out of this mindset as they leave their teenage years. At best, this attitude could be described as adolescent, and at worst this sort of wallowing is pathetic. So much great art has been inspired by natural beauty, or aspiration to create something beautiful, or to prove your love to someone, and to suggest that all art comes from misery is downright mean and cold to the bone.

Have the chutzpa to enjoy something - in the words of South Park:

BUTTERS: Wuh-ell yeah, and I'm sad, but at the same time I'm really happy that somethin' could make me feel that sad. It's like, ih ih, ih it makes me feel alive, you know? It makes me feel human. And the only way I could feel this sad now is if I felt somethin' really good before. So I have to take the bad with the good, so I guess what I'm feelin' is like a, beautiful sadness. I guess that sounds stupid...

GOTH 1: Yeah.

STAN: No. No, Butters, that doesn't sound stupid at all.

BUTTERS: Well, thanks for offerin' to let me in your clique, guys, uh but, to be honest, I'd rather be a cryin' little pussy than a faggy Goth kid. Well see ya, Stan.

STAN: He's right. I don't even know who I am anymore. I like liking life a whole lot more than hating it. Screw you guys, I'm goin' home.

GOTH 2: Go ahead and go back to your sunshine fairytale!

No Butters, it doesn't sound stupid to me at all.

April 09, 2007

Modern psychology makes games more fun.

This post is in reaction to Jenova Chen's recent article in the Communications of the ACM, titled Flow in games (and everything else).

Chen writes an interesting article about how the psychological concept of flow is relevant to modern video game design. The trick is essentially that a game must be sufficiently challenging to significantly captivate the player’s interest, but not too difficult to cause constant frustration. Any dedicated gamer would agree, getting into the “zone” is a highlight of the gaming experience.

While this may sound like common sense, it is useful to have descriptors and measurements for flow, especially when it comes to video game design. Who wouldn’t want a game that is more attuned to that “zone” of creativity and mental acuity we all find so enjoyable?

The concept of flow was introduced by Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi in the 1970s, and is now considered one of the fundamental building blocks of modern psychology. According to Wikipedia, “Flow is the mental state of operation in which the person is fully immersed in what he or she is doing, characterized by a feeling of energized focus, full involvement, and success in the process of the activity.”

According to Csikszentmihalyi there are 8 major component’s of flow:

  • A challenging activity requiring skill;
  • A merging of action and awareness;
  • Clear goals;
  • Direct, immediate feedback;
  • Concentration on the task at hand;
  • A sense of control;
  • A loss of self-consciousness; and
  • An altered sense of time.
Any good video game designer will attempt to touch on as many of these as possible. Chen provides charts suggesting that flow zones for different players will occur at different difficulty levels. Like the GREs, video games that encourage flow will adjust their difficulty levels according to the ability of the player. Some games take a deliberate approach to this – we’re all quite familiar with Halo’s Legendary difficulty setting, for example.

What Chen does not touch upon, and which may be interesting research in the future, is to analyze which kinds of experiences prove to be most fulfilling for different types of users. I am not certain what all the dimensions of measurement should be, but it seems that World of Warcraft could provide at least some basic insight.

World of Warcraft approaches flow in all the right ways, and this is, I believe, the primary reason it is such a popular game. The concept of leveling is not new to the RPG genre, but Warcraft provides just the right amount of difficulty at each level to make the experience rewarding, even if you’re soloing. It succeeds because it provides opportunities for players to engage the game on many different dimensions. If you’re interested in finances, you can play the Auction House; if you’re a team player, there are dungeons and raids aplenty; if you’re a strategic sniper, you can do that; if you’re into narrative and stories, just follow the quests; and the list goes on.

A game needn’t be as vast and multivariate as WoW to promote flow. Seemingly simple games like Checkers, Tetris, or Mario 3 can be just as engaging, though perhaps not to as wide an audience as Blizzard’s masterpiece. The simple “speed-up” of the falling blocks in Tetris was always enough to keep my interest piqued, and the anticipation of what’s just beyond the edge of the screen in Mario could be a great thrill.

For myself, appropriate anticipation of future events in a game is what is most exciting. When I am forced to analyze the current situation, imagine what the future scenarios might be like, and to prepare my character/team/army appropriately, I am most engaged in the process. In Warcraft, the options of what to equip when, whether to use my druid’s cat form or feral form when attacking an enemy, how to cast heals on my teammates appropriately so I don’t run out of mana and so that none of them die; all of these things are what I find most intriguing.

My personal flow also manifests itself in RTS games like Homeworld or Total Annihilation, where the build-up is just as important as the actual fight. Of course, the fight itself often requires as much awareness and pre-cognition (to borrow a term from Philip K. Dick) and is also enjoyable.

What do you find generates the most flow for you?

Hopefully understanding flow will help game designers to create even more engaging games in the future.

March 23, 2007

Software Slump

We've all seen it happen before; a magnificent game comes out of nowhere, holds our game systems hostage, and after the requisite 2 year wait, the sequel feels flat and uninspired. The most obvious and glaring example of this, oddly enough, it is a truly beloved game. You all know it, even Bungie's said it. Halo 2.

Bungie engineer Chris Butcher was blunter in his assessment. "We had about four to five weeks to polish Halo at the end...[but] we had none of that for Halo 2," he told [British game magazine Edge]. "We miscalculated, we screwed up, we came down to the wire and we just lost all of that. So Halo 2 is far less than it could and should be in many ways because of that. It kills me to think of it."

Butcher was even critical of Halo 2's multiplayer element. "Even the multiplayer experience for Halo 2 is a pale shadow of what it could and should have been if we had gotten the timing of our schedule right," he said "I ****ing cannot play Halo 2 multiplayer. I cannot do it."

So what happened? How could a game that had (save a few last weeks) all the time in the world and an incredible base to build from turn out to be so uneven? Halo: CE was the Xbox. There is a real chance that the system might have failed if not for Halo: CE. So what happened?

Halo 2 is the highest profile example of the sophomore slump in videogames, something I've decided to call the software slump. But now that I've got a cute little moniker for this phenomenon, I'm obligated to explain it. Damn.

Crackdown inspired this post, along with the above quotes. Crackdown is incredibly fun to play around with, but at times it feels like some things were left out. Some are basic features that have been left out, possibly due to technical concerns (split screen deathmatch and coop), and others are finer elements of story and depth (more collectible weapons / cars / gear). What I see when I look at Crackdown is a game that should have a tremendous sequel, and that has a lot to do with the fact that it was lacking in the ways I described.

Halo: CE had none of these problems; the game was fully featured and the plot was fairly inventive. It played perfectly, and had very solid balance both in single player difficulty and in multiplayer -- well, you've played it. It was a great game in its own right, so how did the sequel go so wrong?

Don't misunderstand me, I enjoy Halo 2, and still play occasionally. But now that both Halos are 'last-gen,' I don't feel the overwhelming need to play the newer game over the older, and so I find myself suggesting Halo: CE at least as often as Halo 2, especially if we're going to play coop. Halo 2 missed the mark
  • On plot - With the mostly horrible Arbiter sections and the ending

  • On weapon balance - gimping the shotgun, plasma and magnum pistols, adding the tracking feature to the rockets while removing the fuel rod from the Banshee and slowing down the Wraith, and (though it's my favorite thing in the game) adding the unstoppable energy sword

  • On the campaign - by changing the nature of the game and making Legendary difficulty unsatisfying and aggravating in coop, rather than the joy it was in the first game

They added some nice features too. Though I complain about the sword, like I said, I love it so hard, and having it available to the enemy in Halo: CE but not to the player seemed very unfair. Same thing for the Wraith tank, and while I'm on that point, vehicles should be destructible as they are in Halo 2. Dual wielding was overdue and pulled off well.

I think the trouble was that the team got wrapped up in all the new features they were adding to the game and missed the bigger picture. Often times these new features only served to throw off the balance in matches. I think that the story in the game was beyond salvation, but multiplayer was not. Halo 2 multiplayer was fun, but always seemed a bit too chaotic, and never approached the ballet-like matches I remember from Halo: CE. Furthermore the removal of the health gauge in addition to the shield was a terrible decision. Having two levels of life, one that dynamically recharges and the other that could only be revived by a power-up, makes for more strategic matches. Would I assault a superior foe with my spawn guns if I knew I could knock his health down halfway and I could keep him from reaching the health kit on my next life? Do I pick up the health and expose myself to potential ambush? With the addition of so many new weapons to Halo 2, most of which are not expressly superior to any others, there is little interest in setting traps or stalking a player - simply blast away at the next body you see.

Maybe these aren't the problems that Chris Butcher of Bungie was referring to above. Maybe I haven't even noticed what he things makes Halo 2 unplayable. However, these are the problems I see, and they came about because Bungie put too much into features at the cost of the balance and playability of the game.

Crackdown is at the other end of this spectrum. The basic structure of the game is fantastic, but it is almost criminally lacking in features. Split-screen coop is mandatory, period. Even minigames in split-screen, like the already included rooftop races, or see who can throw a body the farthest or juggle it the longest with rockets, or who can kill the most civilians or gang members in a time limit or with a single life. The game also begs for deathmatch, with a redesign in the aiming system (and the ability to hit something you're not locked on to).

A plot, even something as cliche-ridden and bland as Saint's Row would be greatly welcomed, and the fact that you're cloned every time you die could actually be used to write a Phillip K Dick-esque story around. The game bursts with potential. Bosses could use giant mechs, or use similar superhuman powers to the main character, or even use parts of the environment to attack you.

The eventual question I'm pushing towards is - Will a game with tremendous potential, but lacking in features and depth(Crackdown) spawn a better sequel that a game that achieves everything it set out to do right out of the gate(Halo: CE)? A lot depends on the development team, but sometimes it takes drastic changes in focus to make a sequel work for a great game.

The series that jumps to mind as the perfect example of a team trying to make a sequel to a great game, once meeting with success, once with failure, is the trio of GoldenEye 007 / Perfect Dark / Perfect Dark Zero. GoldenEye and Perfect Dark were both smash successes, and PD:Z was sloppy at best. I had tremendous expectations for the PDZ, as PD is in my top 5 games of all time, but besides next-gen graphics the game had little going for it.

I believe that Perfect Dark was able to capitalize on GoldenEye's success without succumbing to software slump because they found features that gamers wanted and needed and implemented them without destroying the balance in the original game. I think losing the Bond license might have been the best thing that happened to PD, since it forced Rare to think of how to pull gamers in without the heavyweight tie-in. This change in focus brought enough freshness to the title to keep us happy without changing the basic feel of the game. This is where Halo 2 stumbled - they lost the feel of the original in pursuit of adding new features and items to the game.

I guess in a few years, we'll know if Crackdown 2 winds up better than Halo 2. I wouldn't hold my breath, since most developers either don't think like me, or find it too hard to code some of the ideas I've laid forth for the game. Still, it's interesting to see that success can sometimes come from mediocrity, and that brilliant success can sometimes lead to lackluster production. Hopefully this won't afflict some of the top tier games right now that are clearly going to get sequels, (Gears of War, Zelda, Resistance) but if it got hold of Halo: CE, then what game is truly safe?